Kiss a frog – No smooches for middle school merger

Posted by Dan Whisenhunt April 3, 2014
King Middle School Principal Paul Brown speaks to parents in the Jackson High Cluster during a meeting about merging King with Coan MIddle next year. Photo by: Dan Whisenhunt

King Middle School Principal Paul Brown speaks to parents in the Jackson High Cluster during a meeting about merging King with Coan MIddle next year. Photo by: Dan Whisenhunt

Learning to like middle school is a little like learning to kiss a frog, Martin Luther King Jr. Middle School Principal Paul Brown said.

Brown made his remarks at the beginning of a community meeting about merging his school with Coan Middle.

The merger idea, proposed by outgoing Superintendent Erroll Davis, didn’t inspire parents to pucker up during the April 3 meeting. Some wanted APS to put off making  a decision until Davis’ replacement is hired.

“I personally would like to see both schools stay open,” said Jennifer Botz, the vice president of the King Middle Parent Teacher Association. “I think it’s very important for children to be able to go to schools in their community.”

Members of the board of education who attended the meeting say the low enrollment at both schools needs to be addressed sooner rather than later. Board of Education members Matt Westmoreland, whose district includes the Jackson Cluster, and Cynthia Briscoe Brown both said the schools need to have higher enrollment to provide an adequate middle school experience for students.

If the Board of Education decides to act on Davis’ proposal, Coan and King Middle would be combined at the end of the 2013-2014 school year. Students in the new middle school would attend classes at the Coan campus for one to two years while King Middle undergoes a $10 to $20 million renovation. Starting in July 2014 the middle and high school principals in the Jackson High cluster would hold a six-month discussion about the future of middle school education within the cluster.

Davis didn’t attend the meeting, and no one from the central office was in the room either. Davis is supposed to make his final recommendation to the Board of Education on April 14. At that same meeting, the BOE will consider approving the contract for Meria Carstarphen, a superintendent out of Austin Texas who is the sole finalist for the job.

So how did we get to this point anyway?

Well, to recap:

After the last round of redistricting in 2012, Coan Middle remained open after an appeal from parents. Then in March of 2013, parents at Toomer Elementary wanted to revisit their idea of turning Toomer into a Kindergarten through eighth grade school. Parents reasoned that it would make Toomer more competitive with Drew Charter School.  But Davis would not support that idea, opting instead to explore other ideas for improving middle school education in the cluster.

Figures released by Atlanta Public Schools during the April 3 meeting show that Drew is drawing a substantial number of students away from Coan. APS estimates that 32.2 percent of students zoned to Coan Middle attend Drew instead. As a result, 50 percent of students zoned for Coan attend middle school there, compared with the 60 percent of students zoned for King. Coan has 261 students in a school with a planning capacity of 1,025, and King has 471 students with a planning capacity of 1,000.

Toomer Elementary Parent Teacher Association President Stacey Martin said that parents need more time to digest Davis’ proposal.

“We haven’t had any time to figure out what just hit us,” she said.

King parents were also critical of the idea. They wanted to know why should they have to move to Coan for a year, and why does their building need a $10 million to $20 million renovation?

Information distributed to parents said that Coan’s population should be merged with King because it has the better enrollment number. Davis’ proposal says the school would be renovated “to reflect current design principles for educational facilities.”

Board of Education member Brown said that putting off important decisions until Davis is replaced would put the new superintendent at a disadvantage.

“If we come to a full stop, we’re not ready for day one,” she said.

About Dan Whisenhunt

Dan Whisenhunt is editor and publisher of

View all posts by Dan Whisenhunt

  • Lewis Cartee

    For both this article and the last one related to the meeting at Coan you used the same source from Toomer. While I can appreciate her position, I believe this is causing your article to lean to one particular slant. Using all available resources to create a very good school versus two water down ones coupled with the simple fact that the number of students do not support a two school model at this time, cause many in the cluster to agree with the merger.

    • Lewis, I don’t disagree that some people like the idea, but the pro-merger perspective didn’t really show up at this meeting. Maybe that’s because meetings like this tend to draw people who are opposed to it rather than people who are for it. Would you like to submit a letter to the editor on this topic? I will be happy to run it. You can submit it to

  • Rick Derris

    Allowing Davis to make wholesale changes on his way out is the epitome of lunacy. He has never done right by the Jackson cluster and I don’t expect him to do it now. Why do this now when a new superintendent is coming in with fresh ideas??
    The whole thing just reeks of under the table shadiness.

New Ben Ad
Banner Decaturish 300x250_April
Decaturish_300x250 V. 3

Receive the Daily Email DIgest

* = required field