Unearthing history in a Kirkwood cemetery

Posted by Decaturish.com October 29, 2014
Cleveland Clay photo: A Confederate flag marks Cleveland Clay's final resting place. He fought with the 42nd Regiment, Georgia Volunteer Infantry, in the Civil War. Photo by Dena Mellick

A Confederate flag marks Cleveland Clay’s final resting place. He fought with the 42nd Regiment, Georgia Volunteer Infantry, in the Civil War. Photo by Dena Mellick

By Dena Mellick, contributor 

October is the time of year when stories of ghosts and haunted cemeteries abound.

In Kirkwood, there’s a small cemetery that’s not exactly spooky, but it does tell a good story. Set back from the street, Clay Cemetery is easy to miss, even if you know you’re looking for the small cemetery at 31 Clifton Street NE. However, it used to be even more difficult to find before neighbors stepped in.

Earl Williamson, the environmental chair for the Kirkwood Neighbors’ Organization, said he and volunteers started clearing the overgrown cemetery about seven years ago. Because of the large amount of debris and overgrowth, Williamson said it took the group about four years to clear all the way to the back of the property.

Along the way, Williamson has done a lot of research on the inhabitants of the cemetery and the Clay family who first used the land as a family burial spot. Behind the grave markers, he’s discovered many interesting stories about the land and the early residents of Kirkwood.

The Dunwoody and Kirkpatrick families often get credit for being the inspiration for the name Kirkwood, an amalgam of the two surnames, but the Clay family was also an important early land holder in what is now Kirkwood.

Jesse Clay Sr. and his family moved to DeKalb County in 1826 from Monticello, Georgia in Jasper County. They bought about 850 acres of land that Williamson said reached approximately from Gilliam Park to Memorial Drive and from Montgomery Street to Palatka Street SE.

The land had been previously purchased as part of the 1821 Indian Land Lottery. DeKalb County had only been created a few years prior to the Clays moving there in 1826.

Nicole Carmolingo, an archivist at the DeKalb History Center, said, “After the 1821 land lottery, the next year, in 1822, they created DeKalb County. DeKalb came from parts of Henry and Gwinnett mainly, and originally DeKalb County was twice the size that it is today … So at that time, the land that was Kirkwood was much more in the center of the county as opposed to the edge of the county like it is now.”

The Clays were subsistence farmers and likely chose the location of the cemetery because it sat on high ground and was near their home, which was believed to be in what is now Gilliam Park.

The Civil War

DeKalb County’s role in the Civil War is well documented, and the war also deeply affected the Clay family. Two sons, Cleveland Clay and Jesse W. Clay Jr., joined Company D of the 42nd Regiment, Georgia Volunteer Infantry, known as the DeKalb Rangers.

Williamson said both fought at the Siege of Vicksburg. Cleveland Clay survived, but Jesse W. Clay did not. While Jesse’s body remained in Vicksburg, his wife, Susannah Clay, was buried in Clay Cemetery 60 years after her husband’s death in the war.

Cleveland Clay was captured at Vicksburg and later paroled. According to Williamson’s research, Cleveland Clay returned to Atlanta and rejoined his regiment, violating parole. Williamson said Cleveland fought Sherman’s army to the coast, and records show he surrendered at Greensboro, North Carolina on April 26, 1865.

Cleveland Clay lived until 1909. He and his wife, Nancy Jones, are buried in Clay Cemetery, along with seven of their children. Williamson has written that Cleveland and “his regiment fought in a total of twenty major engagements.”

The inscription on his grave says, “Home sweet home, there’s no place like home.”

First marked burial photo: This 1861 stone is believed to be the first marked burial in the cemetery. Digital photography revealed a faint "RIP" engraved on the eroded stone. Photo by Dena Mellick

 This 1861 stone is believed to be the first marked burial in the cemetery. Digital photography revealed a faint “RIP” engraved on the eroded stone. Photo by Dena Mellick


The first marked burial in the cemetery was in 1861. Williamson said eventually it became more than just the Clay family cemetery, with six or seven other names buried there.

It also became racially integrated much earlier than most Southern cemeteries.

“We do have family oral history that says that this became an integrated cemetery in 1956 or ‘58, which was like 20 years before federally-mandated cemetery integration,” Williamson said.

He writes on the Clay Cemetery website, “this would make this cemetery a very rare and possibly unique example of integrated burials occurring much earlier than did elsewhere in the South (starting in the 1970s). Two unconventionally marked graves are consistent with West African burial practices. Many others are marked similarly to older rural black burials … Interestingly, the Clay Cemetery was integrated long before Kirkwood’s schools were.”

Bringing the Past into the Present

Williamson said funding and old trees are the two major problems Clay Cemetery currently faces. Williamson and the Kirkwood Neighbors’ Organization (KNO) hold cemetery tours and volunteer clean-up days keep the community interested in the small historic cemetery.

The KNO had a ground penetrating radar survey completed at the cemetery in July of this year and found an additional 70 graves for a total of 166 potential burials.

That kind of preservation work has prevented the cemetery’s history from being lost. Nicole Carmolingo with the DeKalb History Center said, “The way (the Clay Cemetery) kind of chronicles the history of that area, really is unique … A lot of the family cemeteries remain small, closed off, and I really think it’s a testament to that area that this cemetery kept growing and wasn’t forgotten about.”

About Decaturish.com

View all posts by Decaturish.com

  • Chris Billingsley

    Thank you Ms. Mellick for a very interesting story. Your history of Cleveland Clay adds to my personal knowledge of the Kirkwood community. And I appreciate that you included the Andrew Cross battle flag in your photo. It has always been a flag of honor for those who fought during that terrible time. During the 150th anniversary of the Battle of Atlanta this summer, I was told that the cemetery receives no support what so ever from the City of Atlanta. The City of Decatur maintains both the old and new cemetery in Decatur which makes me wonder, who owns the Clay cemetery and are burials still allowed?
    Another interesting cemetery nearby is the Sylvester Cemetery in East Atlanta. I sometimes work in this area and discovered it while driving around lost, trying to find Flat Shoals Road (this is before GPS). I turned a corner, saw this huge cemetery and thought, this is interesting and in the middle of a neighborhood! Buried here is Fiddlin John Carson, the father of country and western music, who was known for singing “Little Mary Fagin” in 1915. I believe a dedicated group of neighborhood volunteers also maintains this cemetery.
    Your article reminds me that the Friends of Decatur Cemetery is again sponsoring a Veterans Day flag event during which volunteers will place a flag on the grave of every veteran. Participating in this is a great way to say thanks to the sacrifices our veterans made to keep us free.
    Cemeteries were never intended to be just a place of rest for the dead. They can unite a community. I hope that the citizens of Kirkwood and East Atlanta continue to grow in appreciation of these treasured spaces. Decatur too.

    • Dena Mellick

      Hi Chris,
      Thank you for your interest in the story and your comments. Burials no longer occur at Clay Cemetery. As for ownership of the cemetery, Earl Williamson said no deed or title for Clay Cemetery has been found, and the cemetery appears to exist “by exclusion.” He says a little more
      on this on the cemetery website: http://claycemetery.org/2014/08/03/history-of-the-land-belonging-to-the-clay-family/

      It’s interesting you bring up Sylvester Cemetery. In addition to Clay Cemetery, it appears members of the Clay family are also
      buried in Sylvester Cemetery and in another family plot in Haralson County, Georgia. Joseph F. Clay, son of Jesse Clay Sr., was granted some of the Kirkwood land by his father, but he later granted the land to someone else, and he and his family moved to Haralson County, where he died and was buried.

      It appears from my research that some of Greenberry Clay’s (son of Jesse Clay Sr.) children and grandchildren are buried in Sylvester Cemetery. Greenberry’s daughter, Rebecca Jane Clay, married Joseph James
      Phillips, and so some of the Clay descendants are under the name Phillips in Sylvester.

      There is a large Sylvester Cemetery folder at the DeKalb History Center, and you’re right, there is an active foundation caring for Sylvester Cemetery and its history. It is fortunate the Kirkwood Neighbors’ Organization has taken an interest in caring for Clay Cemetery and preserving its history as well. There is also a Clay Cemetery folder at the History Center, if you are interested in learning more about some of the people buried there.

Receive the Daily Email DIgest

* = required field